Church History

Icon Heading

Gather with us for fun and fellowship. All are welcome!

1879: The Beginning

In 1879, about 20 Christians banded together and were baptized in Bachelor Run Creek. There were some inactive years, and they re-grouped as a Christian Church on May 25, 1884.


1887: Women with Spirit!

In June, 1887, the Ladies Aid Society gave the total amount in its treasury, $20, to have the evangelist, O.E. Sharp, conduct a meeting. Sixty were added to the membership! Money was a problem, but the first recorded yearly treasurer’s report of 1888 shows a collection of $35.79, and debts of $25.59.


A Pastor’s Salary in 1904

The pastor’s salary in 1904 was $804.66. Collections were $809.18. Ministers were basically paid whatever was received in collections. Some early pastors were paid, at least in part, with commodities.


1895: A Growing Church

Church membership in 1895 was 135. By 1906, the number had risen to 200. There were 58 additions in 1905. The church continued to grow, and needed a new building. The one-room brick church built in 1887 was razed on April 6, 1914. There was a service of prayer, praise and thanksgiving before the razing. Immediately after the service, several of the women took up the carpet.


1914: A Building for the Church

The cornerstone was laid June 18, 1914, and the dedication was Nov. 29, 1914. The original cost was to be $15,000, but reached $20,000. People pledged enough to cover the building costs. Membership was about 175, but nearly 600 from the community, and surrounding counties, celebrated the completion of the building. The pastor at the time was G. Stanley West.

In the next month, there were 13 baptisms. The church increased by 33 members in 1914, and in 1915, by 20. The church was free from debt in January, 1920. A parsonage on South Division Street was purchased – $3000 for the property, and $2,684 for improvements. In 1928, the church interior was redecorated.


1934: The First Constitution

In 1934, the church adopted its first constitution. Enrollment was 135 resident members, and 10 non-resident members. Rev. William C. Aschanhort was pastor – the only minister to serve the church twice. He also served as state evangelist for the Indiana Christian churches.


A Pastor and a Spy!

Rev. Aschanhort appeared in Washington on peace conferences, and was sent to Russia to investigate Communism under the guise of a representative of the Board of Education. He was discovered and sentenced to Siberia. He escaped with the help of a Russian officer who was later killed on this account.


1945: The Parsonage is Sold

During the Aschanhorts’ second term, they moved out of the parsonage, and bought their own home next to the church. The parsonage was sold in 1945 for $4,500. The property of Ammon Oyler on South Center Street was purchased for $1,000 for a new parsonage.


1951: Our First Phone Line

The first telephone was installed in the church in 1951.


1952: The Church is Redecorated

The cost was $4,000 for the work in 1952. Sunday School and Worship Services were held in the basement which was heated by old iron stoves.


1953: Christian Women’s Fellowship is Formed

Ladies’ Aid became Christian Women’s Fellowship in 1953, and Martha Hoffman was the first president of the Christian Women’s Fellowship.


1953: Women Are Included as Chairpersons

The following committees were formed in 1953: Membership, Outreach, Evangelism, Education and Finance. Some were chaired by women, and they began attending Board meetings.


1954: Fire!

Fire broke out in November, 1954. It started in the furnace room, and burned up into the Pastor’s Study and Loyal Berean classroom, and into the kitchen. Fire damaged the stained glass window to the baptistry, and the painting, “The First Easter Dawn”. Pauline Eikenberry, who painted the picture, restored it.

After the fire, services were held for two months in the Presbyterian Church. They had a building and no preacher; we had a preacher and no building! Al Moss teased that the roof didn’t fall in when “those Disciples came down the street!”


1959: A New Property is Purchased

In 1959, the Aschanhort property was bought for a parsonage. The property on S. Center St. was sold.


1964: Fifty Years at 8 E South Street

In 1964, the church celebrated fifty years in our current building. An all day meeting was held in 1964 with a basket dinner at noon. New light fixtures were dedicated. Also in that year, the Humes property back of the church was bought and used as a church annex for several years.


1967: Breaking Ground for the New Parsonage

Ground was broken in 1967 at 104 Meadow Lane. The parsonage was dedicated June 30, 1968. Rev. Craig and family were the first to live there.


1970: The Organ is Rebuilt

The organ was rebuilt and chimes added. The choir seating and pulpit were changed.


1975: A Modern Fellowship Hall

The basement was remodeled. The kitchen was modernized. New classes were formed, and began meeting in the Fellowship Hall. The nursery was moved from the second floor to the basement.


1976: Library and Parlor are Added

In 1976, the office and classrooms on the east side were remodeled into a library and parlor.


1977: A New Constitution

The major change was to turn the Church Board into a Board of Directors.


1979: Our Centennial Celebration

Bob and Jeanne Thornburg plus Cullan and Becky Eikenberry equaled a great singing team. They sang for the Centennial Celebration in 1979.

Total membership was 286. Of this number, 180 were active; 106 inactive. Average church attendance was about 140 in worship, and 100 in Sunday School.


Members who became Ministers

Paul Shields graduated from Johnson Bible College, and was ordained in our church in June, 1954.

Walter Kelly graduated from Johnson Bible College in 1955. While a student there, he served a church in Shelbyville, IN, and was ordained there.

Robert M. Craig graduated from Phillips University in 1966. He got his Master’s and Doctor’s degrees from Christian Theological Seminary.

Kimberly (Wheeler) Stoddard graduated from Christian Theological Seminary, and was ordained in our church in June, 1988.


Long & Faithful Service!

In 1979, it was mentioned that Jack Smith had been a deacon for more than 30 years, and is still serving. It was also mentioned that JoAnn Smith, church organist, had served for more than 30 years, and is still serving. We’re just pointing out that 28 years later, in 2007, both are still serving!


Our Centennial

Kim Holley: July 2017 – Present

Interim Jim Hollis: September 2016 – April, 2017

Herbert “Woody” Slade: August 2009 – July 2016

Interim Sam Davenport: October 2007 – July 2009

Pam Ditson-McCall: March 1999 – September 2007

Neil Allen: August 9, 1992 – August 1998

Gary West: April 8, 1988 – November 16, 1991

Rex K. Loy: August 22, 1982 – March 18, 1988

Larry J. Kuntz: 1976 – 1982

Charles Wickizer: 1970 – 1976

Milton Craig: 1960 – 1970

Ralph Sell: 1958 – 1960

George Whipple: 1953 – 1958

Russell Hensley: 1951 – 1953

Russell Kilmer: 1949 – 1950

W.C. Aschanhort: 1942 – 1948

Hayes Miller: 1939 – 1942

W.C. Aschanhort: 1930 – 1938

Chauncy Piety: 1929 – 1930

Robert Dillman: 1925 – 1929

Homer Eshelman: 1923 – 1924

R.D. Thomas: 1920 – 1923

J.C. Reynolds: 1919 – 1920

G. Stanley West: 1914 – 1918

H.E. Phillip: 1913 – 1914

Nicholas Zilch: 1909 – 1912

Frank Davis: 1908 – 1909

A.B. Houze: 1904 – 1908

Henry Goodacre: 1902 – 1903

M.N. Nethercutt: 1895 – 1896

Rev. Hathorn: 1892 – 1894

L.E. Murray: 1892, one year

Rev. Campbell: a meeting, 1891.

Brother Hathorn: 1888

Rev. Mavity:  1887

O.H. Sharp: June 1887 – evangelistic meeting, added 60

C.J. Saunders: one year

Rev. Plunkett:  six months

James Lily:  1884 – 1886

Various Ministers from Patton and Delphi

Brother Anderson, 1879